West End Theatre Review – The Gielgud Theatre


Playing at the Gielgud Theatre until 4th October 2026, Oliver!, directed by Matthew Bourne (Mary Poppins) comes to London after premiering at the Chichester Festival Theatre in 2024. It follows Charles Dickens’ story of Oliver, a young orphan, who grows up in a workhouse but then is sold to an undertaker because he became too much trouble. Then, escaping to London, he is welcomed into a gang of pickpockets and his trauma seems to be over. However, circumstances change and he, along with his new friends, is once again plunged into hardship and adversity. Will he ever find the love he is looking for?
The performances are second to none. Ava Brennan (Nancy) captures Nancy’s depth but also her innate goodness and humour perfectly. Her powerful rendition of ‘As Long As He Needs Me’ was full of emotion and despair, whilst her ‘Oom-Pah-Pah’ was hearty and joyful. Aaron Macgregor (Artful Dodger) portrays Dodger’s cheekiness and precociousness superbly, and his performance of ‘Consider Yourself’ was full of fun and set the tone for the show perfectly. Aaron Sidwell’s (Bill Sikes) portrayal of the villain encapsulates everything that Sikes should be: menacing, and terrifying. His ‘My Name!’ was skin crawling and cements the character’s power and threatening presence within the story.
The standout performance though, has to be from Simon Lipkin (Fagin). His portrayal is a masterclass in managing to balance humour with emotional depth, and there are some pieces of dialogue that are so well done that it is impossible to know if they are improvised or not. His ‘You’ve Got To Pick a Pocket or Two’ and ‘Reviewing the Situation’ are two of the best performed songs in the show, and succeed in painting Fagin as a father figure to his gang of thieves. The relationship between him and his boys is tender and comical at the same time, and it is very special to see it played out with such great care. In many ways, this environment is the emotional core of the show, and Lipkin does exceptionally well with balancing this father-like responsibility with the responsibility of being the boys’ protector and friend. The show trades the cariactured aspects of Fagin’s Jewish heritage, and makes him more nuanced and layered than the 1968 film did, but still making him recognisably Jewish. He is portrayed as more sympathetic and charismatic than previously, and his moral angst is explored more – which makes him more human.
These incredible performances are matched by the creativity of the creators. The meticulous and superbly detailed set and costume design by Lez Brotherston (Woman in Mind) succeed in placing the show into Victorian London, and the use of the revolve creates a truly immersive experience, and helps to transition the story along. The precise choreography by Matthew Bourne is sharp and clever, and the incredible lighting design by Paule Constable (Cock) and Ben Jacobs (Bring it On) support each other to make the show a visual feast.
This musical is incredibly impressive. It manages to pay tribute to Lionel Bart’s original score whilst making a unique mark on the material itself. I really hope that this show runs for a long time in the West End!
Written by Helena Featherstone



























